Motorhead Articles

Get Your Marketing in Gear

The Revenge of the Analog Car : Why screen fatigue may be increasing demand for physical buttons, knobs and simpler vehicle interfaces.

Shanna Cathey • September 23, 2026
Car dashboard with hand adjusting physical climate controls, overlaid text about the return of analog car interfaces


Physical buttons, knobs, and switches are returning to new vehicles because touchscreen-only interiors have become a usability and safety problem, not because drivers are nostalgic. For restoration, custom and performance shops, that's a validation of something that never really left: tactile controls on the vehicles you already build and modify.


Walk into a restoration shop's install bay or a performance builder's showroom, and you'll find real buttons, real knobs, real switches a driver can find by feel. For years, that felt like a side effect of working on older vehicles. It's starting to look like being ahead of the market.


Why Are Physical Buttons Coming Back in Cars?

The shift has real data behind it, not just enthusiast preference. J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Initial Quality Study found infotainment was the only vehicle category where reported problems increased year over year, driven largely by connectivity issues with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Among owners who reported a distracted-driving incident, 46% pointed to the infotainment system or touchscreen as the source, more than double the 18% who blamed driver-assistance alerts. Drivers want to change the fan speed without hunting through a menu at 65 mph, and manufacturers are finally admitting a touchscreen isn't automatically an upgrade over a knob.


Regulators and manufacturers are responding directly. Euro NCAP is changing its assessment approach starting in January 2026 to reward physical or permanently accessible controls for turn signals, hazard lights, the horn, windshield wipers and the eCall emergency system. Cars that bury those functions in a touchscreen menu will lose points and won't be eligible for a five-star rating. Hyundai's new Pleos Connect system pairs a large central display with physical buttons on the steering wheel and below the screen for the functions drivers use most.


Does This Mean Touchscreens Are Going Away?

No. New vehicles will keep their digital clusters, cameras, connected services, and software updates. The philosophy behind them is what's shifting: navigation and camera views make sense on a screen, while volume, temperature, and hazards make more sense as controls a driver can find without looking. That's a lesson the new-car industry is relearning. It's one restoration and custom shops never had to unlearn, because it never left their vehicles.


Why Do Restoration and Custom Shops Already Have This Advantage?

Because people form real relationships with their vehicles, and older vehicles were built around that fact. A favorite truck has a familiar click when the turn signal engages. A vintage dash has knobs you operate without thinking. Those details create connection, and customers remember how a vehicle feels long after they've forgotten its 0-60 time.


That matters most for shops that work in the emotional side of the business every day. Customers rarely spend serious money on a build because transportation was the goal. They're chasing a feeling, a memory, or an identity they can't get from an appliance. MHD's
Trust, Loyalty & Relationships: The Real Shop Advantage makes a similar point from the business side: automotive decisions run on confidence and connection as much as horsepower or price. The same is true of how a vehicle is designed to be lived with, not just looked at.

Learn More about Our Programs

What Does This Trend Mean for an Aging Vehicle Fleet?

The timing lines up well. SEMA's 2026 Future Trends and Industry Update names an aging vehicle fleet as one of the aftermarket's biggest growth drivers for the year, alongside rising ADAS complexity that shops now have to account for in builds. That builds on earlier SEMA research, which documented a rise in vehicle problems tied to newer technology features, including infotainment and driver-assistance systems, and flagged the trend as a risk to future dependability. At the same time, MHD recently covered how America's 12.8-year average vehicle age is reshaping demand across the aftermarket.


Put those together, and consumers are keeping vehicles longer while growing more skeptical that every new layer of in-car technology actually improves ownership. That's real room for shops that understand personalization isn't only about adding more. Sometimes it's about making a vehicle work better for the person driving it: upgraded switchgear, thoughtfully integrated audio, restoration-style controls with modern electronics behind them, improved steering-wheel controls, retro-inspired interiors, or infotainment upgrades that preserve tactile operation.


What Does This Mean for Your Shop?

  • Market tactile upgrades as a category of their own. Billet switch panels, retro-style toggle kits, and upgraded steering-wheel controls deserve their own service or product page, not a line item buried under general electrical work.
  • Lean into the restomod story. A build that pairs a modern stereo or ADAS-adjacent tech with real knobs and switches is the "best of both worlds" pitch this trend is creating demand for. Say so directly in build descriptions and social captions.
  • Show dash and console work in before/afters. It's one of the most visually satisfying upgrades to feature. Customers can see the tactile difference even in a still photo.
  • Bring it up in consultations. If a customer complains about a rental or loaner's touchscreen, that's a natural opening to talk about what a build at your shop could look and feel like instead.
  • Name it as a choice, not a limitation. Customers researching a build may not realize "keep the knobs" is even an option. Framing it as deliberate, rather than a compromise of working on an older platform, changes the conversation.


After a decade of treating touchscreens as the obvious upgrade, the industry is starting to treat a well-placed knob as a premium feature instead. Restoration, custom, and performance shops don't need to change how they build to take advantage of that. They need to talk about what's already true: the vehicles you work on solved this problem before it had a name.


Frequently Asked Questions

Does the analog car trend mean new vehicles are becoming a threat to restoration and custom shops?

No. If anything, it validates the opposite. Automakers are trying to recreate, through regulation and redesign, something older vehicles and custom builds already offer by default.


Is this about safety or aesthetics?

Mostly safety. J.D. Power's and Euro NCAP's changes are both responses to distraction and usability complaints, not styling trends.


Should performance shops care about this if they don't do full interior restorations?

Yes. Steering wheel controls, switch panels, and console work show up in performance builds too, and the same "best of both worlds" positioning applies to a track-focused build as much as a restomod.


How do I talk about this with customers who assume newer is always better?

Frame it as a usability upgrade, not a step backward. The goal isn't avoiding modern technology. It's putting the right functions in the right place, which a custom build can do in ways a factory production line can't.


If you're ready to shift your shop's website, email marketing, or social media into high gear, contact Motorhead Digital today. Let's build a strategy that drives real traffic, and real builds- straight to your shop doors.


Professional headshot of a woman with long, wavy light-brown hair wearing black-framed glasses and a dark blazer over a light blouse, smiling gently against a warm, rust-colored background.

About the Author


Shanna Cathey is a Colorado native with over a decade of experience in the powersports industry and is a lifelong Motorhead whose roots just happen to be on two wheels instead of four. She currently rides a 2021 Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage 114 and firmly believes most life decisions improve after a good ride.


Shanna brings hands-on experience in powersports sales and service, lead management, business development, and after-sales support, paired with a strong background in CRM systems, sales funnels, email marketing, and content creation. At Motorhead Digital, she helps custom shops and performance brands turn real-world grit into digital horsepower through smart automation, clean design, and copy that actually converts.

By Shanna Cathey • August 20, 2026
The average age of a light vehicle in the United States is now 12.8 years, according to the latest publicly released national benchmark from S&P Global Mobility (the firm completed its spinoff into an independent company, now called Mobility Global, in July 2026, though its research is still widely cited under the S&P Global Mobility name). For the automotive aftermarket, that means a growing population of vehicles entering the years when maintenance, repair, replacement parts, diagnostics, and upgrades become increasingly important. The American vehicle fleet is getting older, and it's changing how aftermarket businesses need to think about growth. S&P Global Mobility reports that the U.S. fleet has grown to 289 million light vehicles in operation. Passenger cars now average 14.5 years old, while light trucks average 11.9 years. The high-volume 2015 through 2019 model years are also moving deeper into the aftermarket service cycle as more vehicles leave their original warranty coverage. For independent repair shops, parts suppliers, restoration specialists, performance businesses, and custom builders, the opportunity is substantial. It is not automatic, however. The businesses positioned to benefit will be the ones prepared to service an aging but increasingly technical vehicle population. Why Does an Aging Vehicle Fleet Create Aftermarket Opportunity? Older vehicles generally require more frequent maintenance and a wider range of repairs. Wear items reach the end of their service life. Seals, wiring, suspension components, cooling systems, electronics, and emissions equipment begin to demand more attention. Owners also start making larger decisions about whether to repair, restore, upgrade, or replace the vehicle. S&P Global Mobility identifies vehicles between six and 14 years old as a prime range for aftermarket service. Its research indicates that vehicles in this age range, along with even older models, are expected to represent at least 70% of vehicles in operation for several years. The newest industry forecast reinforces that opportunity. In June 2026, the Auto Care Association and MEMA Aftermarket Suppliers projected that the U.S. light-duty automotive aftermarket would grow 5.2% in 2026. The market is expected to surpass $500 billion by 2029, supported by the aging fleet, increasing vehicle complexity, and continued consumer reliance on personal transportation. Why Are Americans Keeping Vehicles Longer? High new and used vehicle prices and broader economic uncertainty continue to influence replacement decisions. Many drivers would rather invest in a vehicle they already know than take on the cost of replacing it. Modern vehicles are also durable enough to remain useful well beyond the point when earlier generations of owners may have traded them. From the shop side, the pattern is familiar. A customer says, "I just need it to last another year." Then one year becomes three. The truck remains essential to the business. The SUV stays in the family. The daily driver becomes a project because the owner would rather improve it than start over with another payment. This is where the aftermarket becomes essential. It gives vehicles a second, third, and sometimes fourth life. A 12-Year-Old Vehicle Is Still a Modern Vehicle An older fleet does not mean a simpler repair environment. A 12-year-old vehicle can still contain numerous control modules, emissions equipment, infotainment systems, electronic security features, networked sensors, and early-generation advanced driver-assistance systems. Shops must continue investing in technician training, scan tools, software subscriptions, service information, programming equipment, and calibration procedures. This is also why the Right to Repair issue remains relevant. As Motorhead Digital covered in Part 1: The Right to Repair Fight and the Freedom to Fix Victory , recent federal action created meaningful progress around emissions-related repair information and aftermarket emissions compliance. However, broader questions involving telematics, proprietary software, cybersecurity access, and non-emissions repair data remain unresolved. Older vehicles need more than replacement parts. They need judgment. They need technicians who understand the vehicle as a complete system and can distinguish a smart repair from a poor investment. They need suppliers with accurate fitment data and specialists who can combine traditional craftsmanship with modern diagnostic discipline. Which Aftermarket Businesses Stand to Benefit? Independent mechanical shops can benefit from increased demand for preventive maintenance, diagnostics, suspension work, cooling-system repairs, electrical repairs, emissions service, and age-related wear components. Parts manufacturers, distributors, and retailers can benefit from sustained demand across a wider range of model years. Accurate fitment data, inventory planning, and technical support become even more important when the active vehicle fleet spans decades. Restoration, performance, and custom shops have another opportunity. As replacement costs remain high, some owners will choose to improve vehicles they already own through: Drivability upgrades Modernized electronics Braking and suspension improvements Engine work Interior restoration Full custom or restoration builds The aging fleet is also increasingly diverse. S&P reports that battery-electric vehicles average 3.7 years old, plug-in hybrids average 4.9 years, and traditional hybrids average 6.4 years. Those vehicles will create additional service opportunities as they age, but they will also require new training, safety processes, tooling, and parts knowledge. Trust Becomes More Important as Repair Decisions Get Bigger The owner of a 12- or 15-year-old vehicle may be deciding whether to spend several thousand dollars on a vehicle with limited market value but significant practical or emotional value. That customer is not only buying a repair. They are buying confidence in the recommendation. Shops need to explain: What is urgent What can wait What may fail next Whether the proposed work makes financial sense Which repairs can be completed in phases What can be upgraded Clear inspections, photos, videos, written estimates, and phased repair plans help customers make informed decisions without feeling pressured. Motorhead Digital's Trust, Loyalty & Relationships: The Real Shop Advantage explains why trust often begins before a customer enters the shop. People study reviews, websites, project photos, and social media to decide whether a business looks credible, transparent, and capable. Pricing communication matters too. Older vehicles can expose hidden problems, discontinued parts, long lead times, and changing supplier costs. Tariffs, Pricing Pressure, and How Auto Shops Can Communicate Value Better offers practical guidance for explaining those variables without apologizing for charging appropriately.
Level 7 Motorsports Rebrands Its Parts Store as Spirit and Speed
By Barry Alt • August 5, 2026
Level 7 Motorsports rebrands its performance parts store as Spirit and Speed, featuring an expanded parts lineup and a refreshed Shopify website.
A smiling automotive technician in a repair shop raises both fists beneath a banner.
By Shanna Cathey & Barry Alt • July 22, 2026
The automotive right to repair battle just saw a massive victory with the Freedom to Fix memorandum. Learn how independent shops can leverage this to win.
AI,
By Shanna Cathey • June 11, 2026
AI won't replace your technicians, but it can make your shop faster, sharper, and more visible. Here are 5 practical ways performance, restoration, and custom shops can use AI in 2026.
Macro shot of a workord : “Tariffs, pricing pressure, & how auto shops can communicate value better”
By Shanna Cathey • May 1, 2026
Tariffs are squeezing the specialty automotive aftermarket. Here's how restoration, custom build, and performance shops can communicate pricing clearly, build customer trust, and protect their businesses as costs climb.
Students in Wayne Technical Career Center auto shop posing in hoodies around car body panel
By Keith Bourgeois • April 10, 2026
What started as a car show became a mission to inspire young builders. See how students are gaining real skills while helping preserve automotive culture.
Automotive technician working on a classic blue Ford Mustang inside a professional performance shop
By Shanna Cathey • March 13, 2026
A practical 2026 marketing checklist for custom car, restoration, and performance shops. Learn the essential digital marketing strategies every automotive shop needs to increase visibility, generate leads, and win more builds online.
Two dirty hands shaking, text: Automotive shops prioritize relationships for growth.
By Grace Caple • February 16, 2026
Trust isn't a buzzword in the automotive aftermarket, it's currency. Discover how successful shops build loyalty, earn trust, and create lasting customer relationships that fuel long-term growth.
Image of Porsche in a performance shop in the winter
By Shanna Cathey & Barry Alt • January 21, 2026
Your shop may be slow in the winter, but it's the perfect time to fix your Auto Restoration, Performance, and Custom Build shop marketing. Learn why winter is ideal for systems, strategy, and growth.
AI’s Place in Automotive Aftermarket Shops - PART 2
By Barry Alt • December 13, 2025
How artificial intelligence can power your company’s engine behind the scenes.
Show More